Back in Amish country, Hanna spots a cattle probe hanging on a fence and starts experiencing PTSD. Aria sees it and comforts her, promising that Rollins is going to pay for what he did. Also, if Amish don’t use electricity, then what are they doing with an electric cattle prod?
Spencer and Caleb are having the big talk. He tells her that he’ll always be a little bit in love with Hanna, what with their history, but he’s invested in Spencer, and he wants to make it work. She tells him that she loves him, and he says he likes everything about her. Ouch. Spencer realizes she wants to be with somebody who loves her, and while Caleb wants to make it work, she’s not sure if he’s on her level.
Emily crashes Toby’s engagement party and demands that he drop everything and get to policing. Also, Emily is so nonplussed about Ali MURDERING HER OWN SISTER it’s amazing. Like, that is the least of Emily’s problems with this entire scenario.