As if on cue, Caleb shows up, full of remorse over how he handled things with Spencer. Through the door chain, he tells her about his long-time crush on her, and how he turned down a job in San Francisco to stay in D.C. with her. He’s crying and waxing on about her perfect chin and Spencer is crying and Hanna is listening to everything in the corner like, “I just murdered a man, and now I have to listen to my ex profess his love for my best friend?” Someone get this girl a drink. Caleb tries to get in, but Spencer asks for more time so she can process/bleach away evidence.
Across town, Aria and Ali sneak back into Wellby, but Ali doesn’t want to be locked back up. Aria convinces her that they all need her alibi, plus the world needs to see that Rollins was a monster. So Ali gets back in bed, and Aria shackles her in and puts her Hannibal mask back on. Ali wonders why Rollins would think she killed Charlotte when she spent years trying to free her, and Aria asks her point blank if she did kill her. We FLASHBACK to the church, where Ali chases Charlotte up the bell tower. Charlotte is pissed that Ali and Rollins are dating, because she’s in love with Rollins, but of course, Ali doesn’t know that. Charlotte screams at Ali to leave her alone, so Ali leaves the church, but not before seeing something scurry off in the shadows. Ali is filled with remorse over not staying with Charlotte, and Aria is filled with guilt over serving up Ali to Rollins. It’s a real guilt fest.
At Radley, Emily works the bar and pours Spencer a large martini. They wait for Aria to finish her job, and Spencer is all set to take Rollins’ phone and jacket, buy a train ticket in his name, and put his shit on board. Emily is going to the DiLaurentis house to make it seem like he packed his bags in a hurry. This is actually a pretty well thought out plan, which means it will most definitely go to shit. Spencer gets drunk and tells Emily about the Haleb kiss, and they talk about falling into old patterns in Rosewood. Emily clock out and Spencer continues to build her alibi as drunk, bitter girl at the bar.
